Understanding Permutations with Nested Loops in R

======================================================

In our previous discussion, we touched upon the concept of generating all permutations of calculations using nested loops. While it might seem daunting at first, understanding how to manipulate index variables is crucial for unlocking the full potential of your code.

Background and Terminology

To begin with, let’s clarify a few key concepts:

Permutations: A mathematical arrangement of objects where order matters. In our case, we’re interested in generating all possible combinations of calculations.
Indexing: The process of assigning a unique value to each element or position within a dataset. This is particularly relevant when working with nested loops.

In the context of R programming, indexing variables are used to access specific elements within a dataset. For instance, x[1] would refer to the first element in the vector x.

The Challenge

The original code snippet provided attempts to generate all permutations using three nested loops:

for (i in 1:iter) {
  # ...
  for (j in 1:iter) {
    # ...
    for (k in 1:iter){
      # ...
      index &lt;- iter*(i-2)+j+ k            # Clearly where the error is
      # ...
    }
  }
}

The issue lies in the index variable, which seems to be misaligned with the nested loops. This results in an incorrect calculation, as we’ll explore later.

The Correct Approach

To generate all permutations correctly, we need to re-examine how we assign indices to our variables.

Let’s start by considering a simple example: generating all possible values for i, j, and k within the range of 1 to 10. We can represent these values as digits in a decimal system.

For instance, if we want to generate permutations for i, j, and k, we can assign them the following values:

i: hundreds (1-99)
j: tens (0-9)
k: ones (0-9)

To calculate the index, we multiply each value by its corresponding positional weight:

100 * (i - 1) for i (hundreds)
10 * (j - 1) for j (tens)
(k - 1) for k (ones)

The resulting index would be the sum of these values: 100 * (i - 1) + 10 * (j - 1) + k.

Implementing the Correct Approach

Now that we’ve understood how to calculate indices correctly, let’s modify our code snippet accordingly:

# Define variables for parameter ranges and permutations
iter = 10   # length of parameter ranges to test
perm = 3    # number of parameters being varied

# Initialize data structures for storing results
my_data_c &lt;- vector("numeric", iter^perm) 
my_data_n &lt;- vector("numeric", iter^perm)
my_data_v &lt;- vector("numeric", iter^perm)

for (i in 1:iter) {
  x &lt;- i / 10
    
  for (j in 1:iter) {
    y &lt;- j / 10
    
    for (k in 1:iter){
      z &lt;- k / 10
      
      # Calculate the correct index
      index &lt;- iter^2 * (i - 1) + iter * (j - 1) + k
      
      my_data_c[index] &lt;- x
      my_data_n[index] &lt;- y
      my_data_v[index] &lt;- z
    }
  }
}

my_data &lt;- cbind(my_data_c, my_data_n, my_data_v)

print(my_data)

Example Walkthrough

Let’s walk through an example to demonstrate how the corrected code works:

i ranges from 1 to 10.
j ranges from 1 to 10.
k ranges from 1 to 10.

For the first iteration, we have:

i = 1
x = 0.1

We then iterate through j values from 1 to 10 and calculate the corresponding y value:

For j = 1, y = 0.1
For j = 2, y = 0.2

Next, we iterate through k values from 1 to 10 and calculate the corresponding z value:

For k = 1, z = 0.1
…

Finally, we calculate the index using the correct formula: iter^2 * (i - 1) + iter * (j - 1) + k. This results in an index of 111.

We then assign the values of x, y, and z to their corresponding indices:

my_data_c[111] = x
my_data_n[111] = y
my_data_v[111] = z

This process continues for each combination of i, j, and k.

Conclusion

In this article, we explored how to generate all permutations using nested loops in R. By understanding the correct approach to indexing variables, you can unlock the full potential of your code.

We hope that this explanation has helped clarify any confusion surrounding permutation calculations. If you have any further questions or need additional clarification, feel free to ask!

Last modified on 2025-03-22